Calculating Seismic g-value for Caesar II Using ASCE 7
In Caesar II, seismic loads can be defined using g-values, which represent the acceleration due to gravity as a fraction or multiple of the gravitational acceleration (9.81 m/s² or 32.2 ft/s²). The g-value is a critical input for seismic analysis, as it determines the magnitude of the seismic forces applied to the piping system. Here's how you can determine the appropriate g-value for your analysis:
1. Understand the Seismic Design Basis
The g-value is typically derived from the seismic design basis of the project, which is governed by the applicable seismic codes and standards. Common codes include:
ASCE 7 (American Society of Civil Engineers)
IBC (International Building Code)
UBC (Uniform Building Code)
Eurocode 8 (for European projects)
IS 1893 (for Indian projects)
These codes provide guidelines for determining seismic forces based on factors such as:
Seismic zone or region
Site soil conditions
Importance factor of the structure
Response spectrum or seismic coefficients
2. Determine the Seismic Zone and Spectral Acceleration
The g-value is often derived from the spectral acceleration (Sa) specified in the seismic code. Spectral acceleration is a function of:
The seismic zone (e.g., Zone 2, Zone 4, etc.)
The site class (soil type, e.g., Site Class A to E)
The natural period of the structure or piping system
For example:
In ASCE 7, the spectral acceleration (Sa) is provided for short-period (SDS) and 1-second period (SD1) ranges.
In UBC, the seismic coefficient (Ca and Cv) is used to calculate the base shear, which can be converted to a g-value.
3. Calculate the g-Value
The g-value is typically a fraction of the spectral acceleration (Sa) or seismic coefficient. Here's how you can calculate it:
Formula:
g-value=Sa/g
Where:
Sa = Spectral acceleration (from the seismic code)
g = Acceleration due to gravity (9.81 m/s² or 32.2 ft/s²)
4. Obtain the g-Value from the Response Spectrum
If you have a response spectrum curve (often provided by the project or seismic study), the g-value can be extracted directly from the curve. The response spectrum provides the spectral acceleration (Sa) at different periods, and you can use the peak acceleration value for your analysis.
5. Use Default Values (if Applicable)
In some cases, the project specifications or client requirements may provide a default g-value for seismic analysis. For example:
A typical g-value for moderate seismic zones might be 0.2g to 0.3g.
For high seismic zones, it could be 0.5g or higher.
6. Input the g-Value in Caesar II
Once you have determined the g-value, you can input it into Caesar II as follows:
Go to the Load Case Editor.
Define a new seismic load case.
Enter the g-value in the appropriate field (horizontal or vertical direction).
Ensure the load case is combined with other relevant loads (e.g., operating, sustained, etc.).
7. Verify with Seismic Codes
Always cross-check the calculated g-value with the seismic code requirements and project specifications. If in doubt, consult a structural engineer or seismic specialist.
Summary
To find the g-value for seismic analysis in Caesar II:
Refer to the applicable seismic code (e.g., ASCE 7, IBC, UBC).
Determine the spectral acceleration (Sa) or seismic coefficient.
Calculate the g-value using g-value=Sagg-value=gSa.
Input the g-value into Caesar II for seismic load cases.
By following these steps, you can ensure that your seismic analysis in Caesar II is accurate and compliant with the relevant standards.
Example:
Assume the following seismic parameters for a moderate seismic region:
• SS (0.2s spectral acceleration) = 0.75g
• S1 (1.0s spectral acceleration) = 0.30g
• Site Class = D (Stiff Soil)
• Importance Factor (Ie) = 1.0 (Standard industrial facility)
Step 1: Calculate Design Spectral Accelerations
Using ASCE 7-22 tables:
• Short-Period Site Coefficient (Fa) = 1.2 (from ASCE Table 11.4-2 for Site Class D)
• Long-Period Site Coefficient (Fv) = 1.7 (from ASCE Table 11.4-2 for Site Class D)
SDS = 2/3Ss * Fa = 2/3 * 0.75 * 1.2 = 0.6g
SD1 = 2/3S1 * Fv = 2/3* 0.30 * 1.7 = 0.34g
Step 2: Convert to Caesar II g-Value
In Caesar II, we enter seismic acceleration as a fraction of gravity (g = 9.81 m/s² or 386.4 in/s²):
• Horizontal Seismic Load (SDS-based):
g_Caesar = SDS/g = (0.6*g)/g = 0.6
• Enter 0.6 in Caesar II for X and Z directions.
• Vertical Seismic Load (SD1-based, typically ⅔ of SDS):
g_Caesar = SD1/g = (0.34*g)/g = 0.34
• Enter 0.34 in Caesar II for the Y direction (vertical seismic effect).
Step 3: Enter Values in Caesar II
1. Open Caesar II → Static Analysis → Seismic Load Cases.
2. Select “ASCE” or “User-Defined” seismic method.
3. Enter Acceleration Values:
• X and Z directions: 0.6g
• Y direction: 0.34g
4. Assign Load Case Combinations (e.g., OPE + SEISMIC-X, OPE + SEISMIC-Z).
5. Run Analysis and Review Results.
Conclusion
For a moderate seismic region, a typical g-value for Caesar II is 0.6 for horizontal loads and 0.34 for vertical loads based on ASCE 7. These values ensure a realistic representation of earthquake effects on piping systems.
This blog is intended as a guide to determining the minimum safe spacing of plants and equipment in Oil Refineries, Petrochemical Complexes, and similar installations.
The spacing recommendations will apply in the absence of Clients' standards or supplement such standards where necessary. They are based on current industry practice.
The spacing recommendations aim to ensure that available plot areas are used economically without affecting personnel safety or plant vulnerability.